Without the climate protection efforts of the last 25 years, the tipping points of the climate system—such as the Greenland ice sheet and the Amazon rainforest—would have already been crossed.
This speaks in favor of it
The thresholds are very close. Given that many tipping points occur as early as 1.5°C—and with the world currently at approximately 1.4°C—a scenario without climate action (characterized by higher current emission trends and a long-term warming of 4°C or more) would have reached these thresholds significantly sooner.
19.11.2026
Climate protection efforts have measurably lowered the projected warming trajectory. A reduction of approximately 1°C in projected warming since 2015 represents a significant impact. Crucially, it alters the probability that certain thresholds will be crossed over the course of the century. The report emphasizes that every additional tenth of a degree increases the likelihood of such thresholds being exceeded.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://global-tipping-points.org/summary-report/section-1/Positive tipping points: In the fields of solar energy and electromobility, global positive tipping points have already been crossed. This is partly the result of targeted policy, such as the promotion of renewable energy.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://sciencemediacentre.es/en/node/6031Without support programs (such as Germany’s EEG), emissions trading, and the Paris Agreement, the costs for solar and wind energy would hardly have fallen so rapidly.
19.11.2026
This speaks against it
The claim that a threshold has “already been crossed” is scientifically difficult to substantiate. There is no evidence that a tipping point has been reached for either Greenland or the Amazon. Furthermore, there is the issue of time lag: ice sheets respond over the course of centuries, and over the last 25 years, the degree of warming would have been much the same whether or not climate protection measures had been in place. The major divergence between the various scenarios lies in the future, not in the present.
19.11.2026
The thesis is counterfactual and cannot be proven. It remains an open question whether—and how quickly—renewable energy, efficiency, and structural change would have come about even in the absence of targeted policy.
19.11.2026
Climate protection efforts have not been sufficient. In the specific case of Greenland, the scientific argument tends to point in the opposite direction: despite all efforts, the ice sheet may already have reached a state of instability.
19.11.2026
Tipping thresholds are ranges, not precise values. Corals, for instance, serve as a counterexample: they have reached a tipping point despite climate protection efforts.
19.11.2026
The trend is stagnating. Progress in lowering the projected temperature rise largely belongs to the past. Currently, a rise of 2.7°C by 2100 is anticipated—slightly higher than the previous year’s estimate—and the “gap” relative to the 1.5°C pathway is widening.
19.11.2026
Facts
The Global Tipping Points Report 2025 (160 researchers, University of Exeter) concludes that the thermal tipping point for warm-water corals (central estimate: 1.2°C) has already been exceeded. Current warming stands at approximately 1.4°C.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://global-tipping-points.org/earth-system-tipping-points/For Greenland and West Antarctica, the report indicates with high confidence that ice sheets are at risk once warming reaches at least 1 °C; furthermore, several systems—including permafrost, the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets, and the subpolar gyre—likely reach their tipping point at around 1.5 °C of warming.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://global-tipping-points.org/summary-report/section-1/The tipping threshold for the Amazon has been revised downward to approximately 1.5 °C of warming.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://ground.news/article/coral-reefs-become-first-environmental-system-on-earth-to-pass-climate-tipping-point-report-says_57242cRegarding climate protection, the Climate Action Tracker (CAT) shows that the projection based on current policies was 3.6°C by 2100 in 2015, while today it stands at approximately 2.6°C. According to Our World in Data (based on CAT data), the absence of any climate policy would result in an increase of approximately 4.1°C to 4.8°C.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://climateactiontracker.org/press/release-global-update-2025/Progress has been virtually non-existent for years: according to the CAT update from November 2026, climate policy as a whole has remained effectively at a standstill for the fifth year in a row.
19.11.2026
Sources
https://climateactiontracker.org/documents/1451/CAT_2026-11-12_GlobalUpdate_COP31.pdfIdeas / Solutions
No aspects yet
Opinions
No aspects yet